“my” against. “mine” within the several proprietor possessive

“my” against. “mine” within the several proprietor possessive

“We thus see your providing my and Gregg’s son to school now.” – but I would recommend “the boy” and/or children’s term is more natural than just “my personal and you may Gregg’s guy”?

As i trust Warsaw Will, wouldn’t it still instabang be grammatically proper to utilize “mine” in this situation, if you think out-of “mine” as talking about “my son”? That’s, what if the first phrase is actually that it?:

– Ok, however, I believe Gregg’s guy will happen first-in you to definitely circumstances and then make obvious what “mine” was discussing:

In fact, it is really not very clear on the amazing if or not our company is speaking in the a couple of people. When it is you to, additionally the speaker still desires to discuss one another themself and you can Gregg, i then envision “Gregg’s and you will my boy” could well be more natural than simply “My and you will Gregg’s boy”. Of course there have been two – I would personally favor “Gregg’s and you may my family”, I think.

Hello porsche, I am nonetheless not very sure

– I understand it is really not what you requested, but the far more In my opinion about it, new faster need We see to refer often Gregg otherwise me; each other knows whose kid try with it. When we introduce our very own girl so you can people I don’t consider we usually state, “This will be Gregg’s and you may my daughter”, however, possibly “That is the daughter” or “This is my girl”. Secondly, I think we had be more attending say “my personal man” otherwise “my personal daughter” than simply “my guy”, won’t we? Otherwise when i said before, just explore their term:

Toward example provided about original question, my is correct and mine grammatically hopeless – the rest simply style.

– We agree that that which you state ‘s the cure for this new brand new concern, although people isn’t just throughout the layout, it is more about category of sheer. I recently don’t believe you to “my and you can Gregg’s child” is actually sheer English. It does not sound in my experience such some thing a native presenter would say.

Commonly, We go along with most you said, except for anything

You asserted that the initial phrase is not all that obvious. We differ. All of the variation help with at this point keeps an incredibly particular definition:

can only suggest exactly the same thing. Several would state this really is ungrammatical, having “my” coming very first, in case maybe not ungrammatical, it’s at the least believed rude of the the. Which pronoun move is completely improper, in informal message. For many who speak like this, men and women, “educated” or not, tend to consider you may be an earlier teenager whom can’t put down its cellular phone.

can also simply imply Greg has a child, you have a unique kid, and you may somebody got one another college students to school. While this as well as matical, it is still impolite. Comprehend the review above from the “my”.

Notice, evey solitary one sizes is wholly unambiguous. Possibly are typical grammatical, however some should be eliminated to have explanations stated.

Last, Often, your own opinion concerning need certainly to mention Greg is extremely well drawn. Particularly for cases where Greg and you’ve got a young child together, it might be unlikely to refer Greg whatsoever (making it also better you to “mine” meaans a couple of some other babies). Basic, because of the bringing up Greg, it’s about implied that he is perhaps not indeed expose. If it is actually the case, why would the guy additionally be said? You would simply say

I entirely concur that every sentences you’ve offered are unambiguous, but they’re all of the results of our interpretation of your completely new sentence. Ok, as sbee then requires if it would be ‘my’, the guy do make it clear, in case we make original sentence whilst really stands in the place of that review, i then still think it is unclear. We thinkl that is what We designed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.